In part 1, we had a look at how to buy and setup a file server. Now you may be asking yourself a few questions about how to actually use that thing. The first question we’ll answer is “what should I put on there?”.
Q: What should I put on my file server?
The answer is two-fold: anything you want to access from more than one device, and anything you can’t easily backup automatically otherwise.
In my case, it means everything:
I surely do want to access my music and movies from a variety of devices. I even access them from work.
I’m accessing my pictures only from my laptop, but my wife also wants to access them from her laptop (both laptops have Lightroom installed), so pictures go on the server. It also means they will be backed up automatically – if they were on one of the laptops, it would be difficult to do that since the machine would most likely be asleep when the backup job kicks in, and in this age of SSD-only laptops you’d run out of space pretty quickly anyway.
My code repositories are on the file server too. I check-out the code locally and commit/push changes back on the file server.
Documents, porn, whatever, it’s on there.
Of course there are some caveats. Things may be too slow for you. For instance, if I work in Lightroom, I’ll turn off Wi-Fi and plug the laptop to my home Gigabit network. And even then, it will be noticeably slower than if the pictures were stored locally (but it’s not too bad as far as I’m concerned, since raw picture editing is still the performance bottleneck on my machine). If you’re doing stuff like video editing, that’s not even an option.
When a particular piece of data can’t be efficiently accessed remotely, you can use your file server as the backup device – data would be stored locally on one machine, and backed up automatically to the file server. That’s fine, as long as the backup process is, again, automatic. This generally means the source machine is a desktop computer, so that it’s available during the night, when most backup jobs execute.
I would advise against storing data anywhere else than the file server or an automatically backed-up desktop machine (or otherwise always-on storage unit). Choosing where to put a given piece of data is always a balancing act between where it makes sense, where it’s convenient, and where it’s safe, but remember that, when in doubt, always prefer safety.
The central piece to a data-first methodology is, in my opinion, having a file server.
The reason for this is that you’re going to want to access your data anytime, anywhere: streaming your music to your work PC, your movies to your iPad, or accessing your documents from your phone. You need a secure and reliable to way to store and serve that data, and this is best done with a file server.
(if you’re already about to ask why I don’t just use iCloud or something, you may need to read my introduction post again)
Let’s look at the basics for getting a file server after the break.
The hardware
Requirements
The absolute minimum requirements are a computer that’s connected to your home network, and that is always on. Most desktop computers would fit the job description, unless you’re one of those weird people that actually turn their computers off instead of letting them go to sleep. Ideally, however, that file server should have a few other requirements:
Low power: it’s going to be always on, so it might as well consume as little energy as possible, not just for the cute baby polar bears but for your electricity bill too.
Quiet: that’s important unless you intend to store it away in your basement or something.
Data redundancy: hard drives fail – it’s not a matter of “if” but a matter of “when”. And when it happens, you don’t want to have to recover your data from a backup. It’s tedious at best, and you may lose the last hour of work even if you’re using things like Time Machine on a Mac. Only with “copy-on-write” snapshot systems would you not lose anything, except maybe the file that was being saved when the disk failed. Shadow Copy, a little know feature of Windows available for almost 10 years does exactly that, but nobody really uses it as far as I can tell because Microsoft never did any fancy UIs and marketing like Apple did with Time Machine. And this would mean running Windows on your file server, which would probably defeat the previous 2 bullet points as it would require desktop-grade hardware instead of a smaller dedicated box.
Anyway, I highly recommend you get a file server that handles some kind of data redundancy. RAID-1 mirroring is the minimum (2 disks), variants of RAID-5 with 4 disks are the most common, and anything above that is a nice bonus. With both RAID-1 and RAID-5 you get one “free” disk failure – i.e. you can have one disk dying on you, and if no other disk dies while you replace it and the system rebuilds itself, then you’re all good. Of course, even if it’s quite rare, it does happen that a second disk dies soon after (especially if all your disks are the same model, bought at the same time), so make sure you always have a backup ready (we’ll talk about that later in this article).
Connected with wires: ideally, the file server should be connected via Gigabit Ethernet. You can always hook it up to a Wi-Fi router down the line, but at least you know the bandwidth bottleneck is not at the source. Sure, the latest forms of Wi-Fi can stream HD videos, but how do you think that’s going to scale when you end up having 2 people streaming from 2 different devices while you’re transfering files and there’s a backup job going on? Yeah. If you can, use wires.
Buying a NAS box
Given these requirements, the easiest way is really to go for a dedicated NAS. Unless you want to go through the trouble of refurbishing an old computer of yours, figuring out how to get the RAID controller to work correctly, and finding a place for a box that’s probably 5 times bigger than it needs to be, that is. You could also build a custom PC, but if you’re considering it, then you’re probably able to figure it out on your own (although I may post a guide in a distant future).
A few years ago, ReadyNAS was all the rage for NASes, with Synology not far behind, but since they’ve been bought by Netgear (which was around the time I bought my NV+), ReadyNAS seems to have fallen behind. Now, the top of the line seems to be Qnap, Thecus, and Synology, if I believe those performancebenchmarks.
Have a look at those benchmarks and pick the best models that fit your budget, but do keep an eye out for which configuration is used on each test. For instance, RAID-0 with many bays can out-perform everything else on some tasks, even though in practice it’s probably not a configuration you’d use.
Synology are known to have the more user-friendly administration UIs, so you may want to bias your choice accordingly. You may also be distracted for a while by all the stuff these boxes can do on top of simple file sharing, like BitTorrent clients and web servers and photo galleries and what not. Stay focused on their main role: serving files.
The Software
There’s not much to say about the software. If you bought a pre-built NAS as recommended, it will usually come with its own custom Linux-based OS with a fancy administration UI. You will just boot it, set up the shared folders and permissions, and maybe configure some additional sharing services you may need.
If however you built your own NAS, or are using an existing desktop computer, install whatever you know best – MacOS, Windows, or, ideally, a lean Linux distro. Whatever you end up with, make sure your server is easy to remote into. You’re unlikely to hook up a screen and keyboard to it, so you’ll have to use Remote Desktop (on Windows) or SSH (on Mac/Linux) to do any kind of maintenance work. Note that some Linux distros, like the appropriately named FreeNAS, have a web adminstration panel.
Backups
Once you have your file server running, the first thing you need to do is set up some automated backups.
Let me write this again: YOU NEED TO SET UP SOME AUTOMATED BACKUPS.
I’m not kidding. Don’t say “oh I’m bored, I’ll do it next week-end, I just want to watch Netflix already”. You know perfectly well next week-end you’ll be browsing Facebook and cleaning your house because you had been putting that off for 3 weeks already. So do it now.
Again, if you got a pre-built NAS, this is probably as easy as plugging an external drive to the box and going through the administration panel to find the backup settings. Just do an incremental backup of the whole thing every night to that drive. Bonus points if your backup drive is itself a RAID array.
Your NAS may also have some kind of continuous backup system (sometimes called “snapshots”), so you can enable that too.
If you have a custom box, you’re probably smart enough to setup a scheduled robocopy task (on Windows) or a cronjob running rsync (on Linux/Mac) to backup all your data to a secondary drive. If not, look it up online.
What next?
In the next parts, we’ll discuss a couple things, like what should actually go on that new fancy file server of yours.
I like to think I’m being careful and responsible with my data, especially when I look at what most people do with theirs, so I thought I’d start a new series of posts on the subject.
“Data-first” is about choosing applications, services and devices based, first and foremost, on the data that you will get out of them, or the data they accept as input. It’s important because, at the end of the day, once you’ve quit your apps and turned off your devices, your data is the only thing that’s left, and the only thing from which you’ll start again tomorrow. It’s also the only thing you’ll have when you decide to switch to different applications, different OSes, or different devices.
Who is this for?
Some companies – Apple, Google, Amazon, or Microsoft – want you to trust them with your data. Trust that they will keep it available to you as the technological landscape around us changes. Trust that they will keep it stored for the next 50 years or so. And that they’ll always be there to unlock the files for you. And that they’ll pass it all on to your kids when you die.
If you can trust at least one of them, “data-first” is probably not for you. Instead you’ll choose the path of least resistance where all you have to do is tap a button on your iPad or Kindle Fire, watch that movie or read that book, and forget about it. Did you just rent or purchase? Do you own or merely lease? Does it have DRM? What about maybe switching to another eco-system in the future? Who cares! I applaud your ability to not worry about such things. Be on your way, you blissfully lucky person, I wish you well.
If you’re like me, however, there’s no way you can think that way. Being French means, at best, having a… let’s say: a “healthy” distrust of governments and corporations. Even if I trusted a company right now (which I don’t), I have no guarantee that the next CEO or board of directors are not going to screw their customers over. And this is important when you want to keep consuming your data for a long time. Am I ever going to stop re-watching “Who Framed Roger Rabbit” or “The Shining”? Or stop re-reading any Alan Moore comic? Probably not. And how long is “Game Of Thrones” going to last? Another 6 years, maybe? Remember how things were 6 years ago? Yeah, that was when people were eagerly waiting for the first iPhone to be released, and Netflix was still about mailing DVDs to people.
So no, I will not trust anybody but myself to manage my data for the next 50 years, let alone the next 10.
What is it for?
Keep in mind that the “data-first” approach has nothing to do with services and applications where you’re not supposed to keep any data. This includes iTunes rentals and subscription based services like Spotify or Netflix. I have absolutely no problem with those, which I use extensively.
What it’s for is any data you’ve chosen to purchase (videos, music, books, whatever), or that you have created or shared (emails, IMs, or other social media bullshit). That’s what we’ll be talking about.
“Data-first” posts will be tagged with the eponymous tag, so keep an eye on it for case-by-case studies.
JManga, a digital manga service created less than 2 years ago by 39 of the biggest publishers in Japan, is shutting down in a couple months. Most cloud services related fears became a reality when it was clear no refund or backups would be offered. Check out their “Urgent Message” for more details, but believe me when I say it can’t get any worse:
It is not possible to download manga from My Page. All digital manga content will no longer be viewable after May 30th 2013 at 11:59pm (US Pacific Time)
Everybody then wondered what would happen if ComiXology went down. And funnily enough, just the day before, ComiXology had experienced a massive blackout which left people unable to read any issues they didn’t have in their cache.
This is the moment when the real winners are comic stores… and pirates.
As I said before, and as many others said before me: own your data. Cloud services are fine by me as long as there’s a way to easily backup my stuff on my file server, thank you very much.
After the infamous announcement that Google was shutting down Google Reader, there was a lot of debates around the use of online services, especially free ones, and whether we can trust a company to keep such services up indefinitely.
Of course, nothing can last “indefinitely”, and probably nothing will last until you die. You have to expect that Gmail, Facebook, iTunes, Amazon Kindle and any other service you’re currently using won’t last for more than, say, 20 years (and that’s being generous). You need to plan accordingly.
Always have one foot out the door. Be ready to go.
This isn’t cynical or pessimistic: it’s realistic, pragmatic, and responsible.
That’s what I’ve always tried to do. I choose programs, services and products that don’t take my data away from me. It makes it easier to switch to something else if I need/want to, and it future-proofs what I spend money on.
But that’s where it gets interesting, because Google Reader was pretty open to begin with. Google may have become this data hoarding and privacy raping monster over the years, but one thing they always had going for them was the Data Liberation initiative. With it, you effectively always had one foot out the door. You could, at any moment, download a list of all your subscriptions in an open, standardized format, along with a collection of all your stars, comments, and shares. You may be disrupted for a while because you would need to adapt to a new feed reader, but you could switch, just like you can switch text editors or operating systems.
What’s wrong with the Google Reader situtation has nothing to do with your data, or with using a free service (although that is an important subject too). What happened is that Google Reader became a lot more than a free online feed reader. It became a single choke point for virtually every feed reader or news aggregator in the world. Google is of course to blame for making it a collateral damage of their social-wannabe delusions, but we are equally to blame for letting all those programs like Flipboard, Pulse or NetNewsWire rely on a single service that was never really intended to be used that way. It’s understandable it ended up this way, because relying on Google Reader meant easier adoption for new users and not having to worry about complex problems like data storage, metadata syncing, and interoperability… but it doesn’t make it the right decision either. We are to blame because we were constantly asking for Google Reader support. It became a feature you couldn’t ship without.
The death of Google reader is not about losing a product we love – it’s about breaking an entire eco-system of products and workflows.
Hopefully, we’ll recover and things will be better, but it does bring up another debate: the one about how we rely so much on other single choke points like Twitter and Facebook. Ideally, everything should be federated, like email, but I tried looking at distributed alternatives, and they’re just not working well enough. If the links you share and photos you post are of any value to you, I’d suggest you start looking at data harvesting solutions. I know I am.
These past few months I’ve seen a fairnumber of articles about people who switched from iOS to Android. Most of those articles talk about the differences between the 2 operating systems, and how some of those differences proved to be significant enough for whoever was switching: multitasking, notifications, the so-called “open vs. closed”, etc. That’s fine, but these specific bullet point list vs. bullet point list comparisons seem to be missing the higher level view of what’s really going on: iOS is just not working the way it should anymore.
When iOS was released in 2007, it made a lot of things easier to do on a phone, compared to the existing competitors. A lot of tasks just felt “right”, or at least “way better”. But it basically stayed there since then. The only real additions, like the notification center or iCloud, are either incredibly badly designed, or are only usable if you have an almost exclusive Apple-based household (which you shouldn’t). When I look at my iPad now, I feel like I’m looking at a computer that hasn’t been updated in years.
If I’m reading something in Safari, I should be able to quickly send it to Pocket, Buffer, Dropbox, or whatever other service I choose to base my workflow on. But on iOS, the only “sharing” services I have access to are those that Apple thinks I should use. For everything else, I need to copy the URL, switch to another app, and find where to paste it. Why?
If I added a few articles to read on Pocket late yesterday evening, I should have them ready on my phone or tablet the next morning so I can read them during the commute. But on iOS, I have to remember to open the Pocket app so it can sync. Why? (note that other apps like Instapaper try to use the Location Notification API but frankly, by the time I leave the house, and therefore lose any WiFi connectivity, it’s already too late).
If I just bought a bunch of PDFs from DriveThruRPG, e23, Arc Dream or Pelgrane, or some comicbooks from Panel Syndicate or Thrillbent, or whatever else I want from whoever I feel like giving money to, I should be able to just download those files onto my device and open them with any application I like. But on iOS, unless it’s coming from iTunes (directly or via in-app purchases, all of which also means 30% of my money doesn’t even go to the people I want to give my money to), I have to jump through many hoops, going first through Dropbox or FileBrowser and then having to re-transfer every. single. file. to each of their application’s sandbox storage. Why? Oh why?
You may not be surprised to learn that all of those things “just work” on Android. And those are just examples of the frustrations I’ve had with my iPad in the past few weeks. You don’t just go “BOOM!” anymore – quite the contrary: you actually have to work harder to make things happen.
Some people might be tempted to boil this down to a simple list of features, like “iOS needs a background service API, shared storage, and more extensibility points for 3rd party apps”. This sounds to me like going back to 2007 and saying “Windows Mobile needs to make the stylus optional, have a grid of icons on the home page, and remove copy/paste”. Really, it’s not just about a bullet point list of features. It’s about the whole philosophy of the system, and of the company behind it. And although Apple seems to be occasionally bowing down to the pressure of the market, like when it released the 7″ iPad Mini, I don’t expect it to change this radically on the design of iOS.
Would I rather have an iPad Mini instead of my Nexus 7 to bring with me everywhere I go? Of course I would. The iPad Mini is thinner, lighter, and has a better screen. But as someone famous once said, “[design is] not just what it looks like and feels like. Design is how it works”. And for me, iOS is just not working well enough. And it never did, really – it’s just that until the competition caught up with the basics, only a minority of users noticed it.
Jeff Atwood posted another one of his controversial, opinionated articles on his blog, this time about To-Do lists. It’s a long rant about the failure of To-Do lists.
As a former Remember The Milk user and fan, I can totally relate. I just stopped using To-Do lists altogether a couple years ago. I just didn’t need them anymore – I knew what I needed to do most of the time:
If you can’t wake up every day and, using your 100% original equipment God-given organic brain, come up with the three most important things you need to do that day – then you should seriously work on fixing that.
But the truth is: I’m still using some form of list, especially since Trello came around. It took me a while to realize the difference between the Getting-Things-Done-ish productivity I tried to achieve in the past, and the more zen-like – and effective – process I have now.
[…] increasingly, my to do list is full of the things I park there that otherwise get in the way of what I’m actively focused on.
My To-Do lists (hosted on Trello) are filled with stuff I don’t want to do right now, but need to remember for later. I know what I need to be working on right now, but I may forget about stuff I may want to do later. It’s more like a notebook than a To-Do list, really, but the To-Do list format makes it easier to cross things out if they become invalid or if I already did it.
You can see this kind of headline all over the web these days, especially with Apple fanboy tech bloggers: the PC is dead, all hail tablets and smartphones. The argument is also made for video games consoles, who are supposedly on the way out to be replaced by, guess what, tablets and smartphones. Even Jeff Atwood is getting on the bandwagon.
I don’t disagree with the facts here: most indicators we have on the market right now show that, indeed, desktop and laptop computers have declining sales while mobile products have an ever-accelerating growth.
Some tech bloggers, however, are a bit too quick to equate opposing trends with replacement – in reality, people still own PCs and Macs, but complement them with mobile devices. As far as I know, there’s no evidence that anybody is actually getting rid of their laptops and desktop computers after buying an iPad… yet.
Main device of choice
Interestingly enough, Jeff Atwood recently posted an article about the ASUS Zenbook Prime (which, incidentally, is the laptop I bought my wife) as being “the last laptop he may ever buy”. He argued that, more often than not, he would choose a tablet or smartphone when deciding what device to use or take with him, leaving the laptop behind (which sounds dubious from a guy who must spend most of his time in Visual Studio, but whatever).
This, indeed, points at actual replacement. But look at the way he supposedly makes his decision:
Want 10 hours of real world battery life?
Want to start doing stuff immediately?
Want the smallest most portable device you can get away with?
Want to be always connected to the Internet?
Want easy access?
Those are never the questions I have in mind when deciding what to put in my backpack, or what to take with me around the house. Those are just specs. Some are laughable (seriously, you can’t wait 2 seconds for the laptop to resume from sleep?), and some are kind of obvious (well yes, I won’t take anything too bulky or impractical on the bus, but that’s as applicable to a laptop as it is to a large book, my drawing equipment, or my bass guitar, which I would otherwise very like to take with me always), but they’re all besides the point.
Instead, there’s only one question I ask myself: what do I want to do? And then just take what lets me do exactly that, given the environment in which I intend to do it.
For me, this is almost always the laptop – and I’m not the only one. Some of it is my own personal tastes and workflows (the need for a real keyboard, a big enough screen, a connection to my file server), some of it is because of the software I need to run (Lightroom, Visual Studio or any other development environment, Mercurial or Git, Pro Tools), and some of it is the necessities of the task at hand (using a Wacom tablet or Cintiq, using a high-speed audio interface with several music instruments and microphones plugged-in). All of this basically prevents me from using a tablet even if I wanted (which I don’t really).
It’s also the only device I take with me to bed or when leaving the house. Is that a shortcoming of laptops then? Absolutely not. I never planned to write code or tag photos or record music in a crowded subway before, and that hasn’t changed. What I would plan to do is read something, and that’s why I always carried a couple books with me all the time.
Now I just carry one small tablet. It’s not because it’s small or because it has better battery life or because it turns on right away. I have it because it’s the best digital replacement for books (I don’t carry a Kindle or other e-book reader because I tend to read a lot of comics or other illustrated books like RPG books).
For me, the tablet is a definitive improvement (less physical books cluttering the house, lighter and smaller backpack, more pleasant reading experience), but it has barely replaced anything I do on the laptop. The only thing it did replace is Google Reader/Facebook/Twitter in a browser.
I also hear a lot of people saying a phone or tablet is better for quickly checking emails, or looking up something on the web, or whatever. Although I did use my mobile devices for that at the beginning, I found that it was not that much of an improvement. This is because:
I stopped compulsively checking my emails and notifications through the day. Now I’m only doing that a few times a day, which means that when I do I will probably have several things to delete/archive/reply to, and that’s just quicker to do on the laptop (you do use keyboard shortcuts, do you?).
I have a lot of productivity shortcuts set up on my system. I can look something up on a map or on Wikipedia or IMDB or whatever in less time on the laptop than on my iPad. I know, I actually tested that.
One of the exceptions is looking up recipes. My wife got me a fridge stand for the iPad for when I’m cooking. It’s also easier to clean grease marks on a screen than on a keyboard. But, again, that didn’t replace using a laptop: before I would have a recipe book open on the counter.
The post-PC era
Now, we can try to imagine how this is going to change in the next few years. I wouldn’t be surprised if, at some point, your phone could be paired with an external display, on top of a mouse and keyboard, and get into a mode where it’s running a full-fledged (or legacy) OS that can run more complex applications. In the future, your phone could very well be your wallet, your identity, and your one and only computer, with some storage and possibly computing power extending to the cloud.
Is that when the PC will effectively be dead? No. That’s just when your phone will have evolved into your PC. That’s what Jeff Atwood really hints at:
Our phones are now so damn fast and capable as personal computers that I’m starting to wonder why I don’t just use the thing I always have in my pocket as my “laptop”, plugging it into a keyboard and display as necessary.
The “post-PC” era is really about moving past some existing form factors and into new ones. But if you could plug your phone into a keyboard and display to run Visual Studio or Lightroom or whatever, what do you really have? Well: a very small desktop computer.
We went from cabinet-sized PC to desktop PC to smaller PCs to, well, phone-sized PCs (yes, they already exist), but only with smartphones and tablets did the industry embrace new UI designs and input methods. And the danger, here (apart from the attached problems of vertically integrated services and other monopolies), is to think it’s a panacea.
I’m looking forward to see how it will continue changing the market, but meanwhile I’ll keep using my laptop. You know, the one that keeps getting lighter and thinner while gaining multi-touch trackpad capabilities. Thanks a lot for that, by the way.
A few months ago I set out to get a new laptop for my wife. She only had one requirement, after having shared a Macbook Pro with me for the past couple years: that it ran Windows (queue OS flamewar).
I quickly decided I wanted to give her something slick and light, and look at the new line of ultrabooks. I then narrowed the choices down to the Samsung Series 9 and the ASUS Zenbook by reading reviews online… but that was just the easy part.
Much has been said already about the shopping and out-of-the-box experience of PCs, compared to that of Macs, but I think we should keep beating that dead horse until it’s underground. So keep reading for much deceased equidae action.
Getting your hands on the stuff
The first step is to actually get your hands on the models you’re looking for. But if it’s easy with a Mac – just walk into any Apple store or Best Buy or whatever – it’s not that easy with a PC.
Different stores carry different models, have different deals with manufacturers, and have different supply chains. Even given one store franchise, the availability of models will vary from store to store, and that’s not counting which ones are actually available on display: for some reason, a lot of stores wouldn’t let you touch expensive laptops like the 2 ones I wanted to try. Paradoxically, the Apple mini-store located in the next aisle would always happily provide multiple copies of each of their devices for people to play with.
In my case, London Drugs (here in Vancouver, Canada) was one of the only stores to carry the 2 models I was looking for – the whole point being to compare them side by side. But it still took me several visits to several stores all around town to find one with both units actually on display.
During my search, I got some interesting tidbits of information from sales people:
High-end laptops are already well taken care of by Apple, so shelf space is reserved for feature, mainstream, or budget oriented models from PC brands. Windows power-users therefore get forgotten in the process.
Some stores have issues securing those new ultrabooks, so they end up not having them on display at all. Unlike Apple, which provides appropriate locks for the Macbook Air, other manufacturers leave it up to the stores, who often use generic, bulky locks. But those locks often don’t work with ultra-thin cases… and when they do, they’re almost as heavy as the laptop itself, which completely ruins the experience of trying it out.
I eventually managed to test the models I was considering, and quickly decided the ASUS Zenbook would work better. Good news: the Zenbook Prime was just about to be released, with a much nicer body design and a supposedly better trackpad… so after a couple weeks waiting for that one to show up in store, I came back home one day with my precious gift.
Stickers
The Zenbook is a beautiful machine, but like many PCs it comes with a bunch of ugly stickers. This is always totally baffling to me: what’s the point? Are people going to look at your laptop at Starbucks and go “I see your laptop has an Intel CPU inside! Mine too, this is so awesome! Much better than AMD, don’t you think?”.
No, all they do is waste 5 minutes of your time as you remove them and then clean up the sticky bits that they leave behind.
The silver lining in this case was that all 3 stickers that come on the Zenbook are mostly in grey-ish tones similar to the laptop’s body – no flashy ugly colors here. So it’s not completely horrible. Just annoying.
Bloatware
Another expected downside of buying a PC: all the bloatware that comes pre-loaded with it. Everything, from the moderately useful to the totally useless, can be found on the Zenbook once you boot it up. I counted around 20 “utilities” installed.
Of course, I opted for the usual practice of wiping everything and installing a fresh Windows on it. I had to fight the BIOS for a long time, trying to get the default GUID Partition Table to work with my bootable USB key. But the UEFI boot mode wouldn’t work for some reason, so eventually I gave up, re-allocating the whole hard drive as a more classic Master Boot Record partition. It’s kinda sad, this being 2012 and all, but as I understand it, I’m not losing much when it comes to a single 128Gb partition.
Of course, once Windows is installed, the fun has only begun: you still have to go to ASUS’ website to get the drivers for all kinds of components, along with downloading a whole bunch of updates from Microsoft.
Conclusion
The Zenbook Prime, once you’ve been through all those hoops, is a wonderful little machine. It looks gorgeous, is very portable, and the performance is pretty good. The accessories are also nice, especially the leather-ish case for both the laptop and some of the cables. The power cable is the only poorly designed component in the whole package in my opinion, but overall, I recommend this laptop highly.
But going through all these steps was pretty tedious. In comparison, the shopping and out-of-the-box experience of a Mac goes along these lines:
Go into any computer store.
Try any Macbook.
Give lots of money.
Boot it up.
I guess Microsoft Stores and Samsung Stores and the like are trying to address the issue, but it’s a long way away.
In the main article about the road to Diaspora, we looked at setting up our own pod to interact with the Diaspora federated community. Now we’re going to look at how that actually works. Or not. Because since I set up my pod a few weeks ago, I’ve had nothing but problems.
The river of problems
To give you an idea of how bad Diaspora is, even after a couple years of development, look no further than the bug tracker on their Github project page. After a week of using my pod, I had already posted half a dozen issues – and that’s for just one user on a lonely pod. I wasn’t following a lot of people either. Some of those issues have been closed, some are still open. But the point is: this is not good for a project that’s been in beta testing for so long.
Then, there’s the performance issues. Ruby on Rails has never had a very good reputation in this department, but I thought it was mostly a “haters gonna hate” kind of reputation, or some remnant of the framework’s early days, when it was not necessarily very optimized. But after running Diaspora, I’m revisiting my opinon. On an Ubuntu VM with 512Mb RAM, the thin server that runs Diaspora is the only process that ever got killed for running out of memory – neither WordPress or MediaWiki or anything else ran into this situation. And that happens on a regular basis. We’re talking a couple times a day on average. And don’t even think of running a Rails console at the same time: it may work for a while, but you better get done quickly because one of the 2 processes will die soon enough.
And then there’s the whole “federation” aspect, which is the whole point of Diaspora. Spoiler warning: it doesn’t work. I don’t know if it’s related to the performance problems above (the process could be dropping important bits of information when it gets killed) but I always seem to be missing posts and updates from anybody else that’s not on my pod. Doing some testing between my pod and a few other well-known pods like joindiaspora.com or diasp.org, I get completely random results: sometimes a comment or “like” gets propagated in a few seconds, sometimes it takes hours, and sometimes it just doesn’t show up at all on one end or another.
I could go on and on about all kinds of little problems, from the completely stupid “PersonName started sharing with you!” email that doesn’t make any sense (because it means they’re following you, which means they won’t share anything with you unless you follow them back) to some weird design decisions around hashtags (try figuring out how to follow hashtags from other pods) to some obvious problems that never seem to get fixed (like useless Diaspora links to your Twitter cross-posts, or the inability to cross-post public posts to Facebook). I guess that’s what the Github bug tracker is for but, again, this really doesn’t look like a project that’s more that 2 years old.
Diaspora’s future
The original Diaspora founders recently left the project, saying they’re “giving it back to the community” while they “take the back seat”, a.k.a.Makr.io, a very stupid website concept. Some people say that’s the death of Diaspora, but judging from the state of it, it may actually be what saves it. The project was obviously badly managed and designed from the start, so maybe, just maybe, having a community of better programmers take over the codebase would make it viable.
There’s also the very, very slim possibility of someone either re-implementing Diaspora using a different framework than Ruby on Rails. Diaspora is mostly based on open standards – although the keyword here is “mostly” – so it would be possible to rewrite something from scratch that’s compatible.
There’s also the very, very slim possibility of someone writing something else that works better. Mike Macgirvin, the creator of Friendica, recently started working on “Project Red”, which is “Friendica taken to the next level”. His announcement didn’t hesitate to make fun of Diaspora:
Friendica WORKS today (unlike similar projects which are still struggling at basic communications after two years, and after squandering huge amounts of money).
Seeing how Friendica works and is easily installed – even though it’s ugly and useless to me – Project Red could be a good thing if it’s based on asymmetric relationships and Mike can enlist the help of a moderately talented web designer.
In the meantime, I don’t think we’ll get people away from Twitter and Facebook any time soon.