A rant on Ars Technica:
I wanted to love the Apple TV remote. It was sleek and futuristic. Plus, it had an accelerometer and its own little trackpad. Besides which, I didn’t think I’d really need the remote, anyway, since I could simply tell the TV what I wanted to watch. What wasn’t to love? Turns out, pretty much everything.
I largely agree. After Apple added 3rd party app support on the Apple TV, I considered it for a bit (I don’t care about the iTunes eco-system, I’m mostly a Plex + Netflix kind of guy, but I’m interested in getting AirPlay/mirroring working between my iPad and the TV). However, after test-driving the new remote and asking friends about it, I realized I didn’t like it at all. It really felt like one of those times where Apple designers care more about how it looks that how it gets used. The Roku remotes are not perfect but immensely better as far as I’m concerned.