Ramblings of General Geekery

Some Comments on the Ennie Award Winners

Gen Con 2019 is over and the Ennie Award winners have been announced!

My first thought while going through the list is that the venerable Masks of
Nyarlathotep has still got it. The new edition grabbed the Best Adventure award,
probably thanks to Chaosium not only further expanding the text but also adding
high quality art and fixing some of the most egregious problems with the gender
and ethnicity of NPCs. Plus, the HPLHS got 2 Masks-related awards, one for
their prop set (which, sadly, I got only after my group ended the
campaign…) and one for their radio show, which is a lot of fun to
listen to.

Call of Cthulhu in general was well represented with a bunch of other awards for
the new Terror Australis edition, the excellent Starter Set, and
the new Cthulhu Invictus guide.

Some “Call of Cthulhu-adjacent” things also won a few spots, with The Fall of
nicely grabbing the Best Setting award, and other awards
going to the Miskatonic University Restricted Collection board game,
Sandy Petersen’s Cthulhu Mythos for 5E, Seth Skorkowsky’s YouTube
(I only started recently but I like it so far), and the ever
entertaining and informative Ken and Robin Talk About Stuff podcast.

Finally, Chaosium grabbed a few other non-Cthulhu-related wins with the
gorgeous RuneQuest slipcase winning Best Interior Art and, again, overall
Best Publisher award (this time gold!).

So yeah, Chaosium and Call of Cthulhu did quite well this year… Eric Tenkar
was asking over in his tavern why that is, but if you look at the
past two years of Ennie awards, they had also been doing
quite well back then too. That said, I think there’s a few factors at play:

  1. The fairly recent 7th edition line is chugging along nicely, and is very well
    done overall. On a personal level, it’s actually the first time I’m genuinely
    interested in running CoC with the vanilla rules, instead of using something
    else like GURPS.
  2. The rise of podcasts and actual plays came with a fairly high portion
    dedicated (or adjacent) to horror roleplaying in general and CoC in
    particular, including past Ennie nominees and winners.
  3. With Pathfinder and D&D 5e being smashing successes, the explosion of actual
    play podcasts and videos, and pop culture pushing RPGs back in the zeitgest,
    it seems like the hobby grew a lot in the past decade… and surely, by now,
    a good chunk of these new gamers must be looking for new/different stuff to
    play. CoC is a frequently recommended thing to try to anybody asking if
    there’s anything else after D&D.

There were a few surprises for me:

  • The Invisible Sun Black Box not winning the Best Production Values
    award. I mean, have you seen this thing? It’s the most fucking impressive
    thing on my bookshelves, but I guess very few people own it given the high
    price point, hence the lack of votes, maybe.
  • The RuneQuest slipcase not being even nominated for Best Cover Art, and
    The Fall of DELTA GREEN not being nominated for Best Layout and
    Design. Such a shame.

The point of the Ennies is also partly about discovering some new cool stuff:

  • Mothership: I hadn’t heard about this one before but hey, if “sci-fi
    horror RPG
    ” wasn’t enough, you got me at “dangerous derelict spacecrafts”.
  • Forbidden Lands: I had been wondering about getting that one since it’s
    bound to be as gorgeous as the Tales from the Loop books, and I like
    dark fantasy. I guess it’s next on my shopping list!
  • Kids on Bikes: I already had the PDF but hadn’t read much of it. It’s
    now next on the reading list.
  • Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay and KULT: Divinity Lost: I hadn’t
    thought or heard of Warhammer or KULT for a long time, so I was surprised to
    see them coming back with new editions. Nice!

That’s it! Now if only I could some day make it to Gen Con…